
Client Alert
Crossing Into a New Era: SEC Proposes Modernizing Cross-Trading Rule
share this page
The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) on October 9 announced proposed amendments to Rule 17a-7 (the Cross-Trading Rule) under the Investment Company Act of 1940 (1940 Act).[1] The amendments would modernize and expand the Cross-Trading Rule, which permits transactions in securities between a registered fund and its affiliates under certain conditions. The proposal is a welcome modernization for funds and their advisers in a number of ways, including that it would reestablish the ability of funds to cross trade most fixed-income securities, lower transaction costs and facilitate more efficient portfolio management, and rationalize board oversight obligations with respect to these transactions.
Expanded Scope of the Cross-Trading Rule
The SEC seeks to amend the Cross-Trading Rule by expanding the scope of securities that are eligible to be cross traded to “expand the benefits of cross trading to more funds and shareholders while protecting investors from the conflicts of interest implicated by cross trades.” [2] Registered funds previously relied on the Cross-Trading Rule to cross trade equity and fixed-income securities. In December 2020, the SEC adopted Rule 2a-5 under the 1940 Act, which defined the term “readily available market quotations,” including for purposes of the Cross-Trading Rule.[3]
Most fixed-income securities do not have readily available market quotations under this definition, which made such securities ineligible to cross trade. The proposed amendments would permit cross trading of securities that are valued based on “observable inputs” (sometimes referred to as “level 2 securities”), which would include most fixed-income securities.[4] Certain illiquid and thinly traded securities (e.g., securities valued based on significant unobservable inputs, or “level 3 securities”) would continue to be ineligible to be cross traded under the proposed amendments.
Pricing of Cross Trades
In connection with the expansion of the Cross-Trading Rule, the SEC also proposed to amend the rule to provide alternative methods for pricing cross trades at the “independent current market price,” which would be either: (1) the value of the security determined in a fund’s next net asset value (NAV) computation on the business day of the cross trade (NAV pricing); or (2) a price that reasonably represents the current market price as determined by a fund’s adviser using one or more unaffiliated pricing sources (current market pricing).[5] A fund would be permitted to use either methodology for different cross trades.
Transaction Fees
Under the proposed amendments to the Cross-Trading Rule, the SEC proposed to retain the Cross-Trading Rule’s prohibition on transaction fees and commissions but permit de minimis payments to unaffiliated parties for services provided for clearing, settlement, custody, recording or reporting of a transaction.[6] In the Proposing Release, the SEC stated that determining whether a payment is a de minimis amount would be a fact- and circumstance-specific determination and that the amount “would be small relative to the size of the transaction — and below what a fund would pay in brokerage commissions, bid-ask spreads, mark-ups and mark-downs or otherwise if the fund were to purchase or sell the security in the market.[7]
Best-Interest Determinations
The SEC’s proposal would also require that an adviser to a fund engaging in cross trading make a best-interest determination prior to the cross trade. Specifically, an adviser would be required to “determine prior to the cross trade that the cross trade is in the best interest of each registered fund involved in a transaction (which determination, for the sake of clarity, is not dependent on any benefits enjoyed by another fund to the cross trade).”[8]
Additionally, the proposal would require that a cross trade be both consistent with a fund’s policies and procedures as well as its investment strategies. In the Proposing Release, the SEC outlined several factors that an adviser could consider in making this determination, including, among others: the investment rationale for the cross trade and the anticipated effect of the cross trade on fund performance, the characteristics of the cross-traded security, and the method of pricing the cross trade.[9]
Oversight
The proposal would remove the Cross-Trading Rule’s requirement for a fund’s board to approve cross trades at least quarterly and that the board adopt and approve any changes to a cross-trading policy. In place of these requirements, the proposal would require a fund’s chief compliance officer (CCO) to conduct quarterly reviews of a fund’s cross-trading activity, along with annual back-testing of cross trades. The annual back-testing would include a review of other transactions and other information that would be necessary for a fund CCO to determine whether the fund was disadvantaged by cross trading.[10] The fund CCO would then share reports on a quarterly and annual basis with the fund’s board as part of the board’s oversight responsibilities. The SEC states that this reallocation of oversight responsibilities is meant to allow a fund’s board to “focus on larger issues, including conflict of interest concerns, arising out of the CCO’s reports, rather than a more granular focus on whether each cross trade complied with the fund’s cross-trading policies and procedures as currently required under rule 17a-7.”[11]
Reporting and Recordkeeping
The proposal would add an additional requirement for funds engaging in cross trading: to report periodically on Forms N-PORT and N-MFP, respectively, aggregate information “about the value of securities a registered fund traded during the preceding month and corresponding information about cross-trading activity by asset class.”[12] This requirement, according to the proposal, would provide useful information to the SEC and market participants on the relative frequency and volume of cross-trading activity compared to overall market activity.
Additional Amendments and Prior Staff Guidance
The SEC stated that to the extent the proposed amendments are adopted, any prior guidance, no-action letters or staff statements that are inconsistent would be superseded.[13]
Key Takeaways
The proposal is an important step in modernizing the Cross-Trading Rule and is generally consistent with prior industry requests for changes to the rule. Key takeaways from the SEC’s proposed amendments include the following, among others:
- The SEC offered several factors that an adviser should consider in making the best-interest determination. Commenters should consider whether those factors should be amended or supplemented to reflect any additional factors that could be dispositive in making the best-interest determination.
- The SEC proposed amendments to calibrate required compliance policies and procedures and recordkeeping requirements that would, if adopted, require advisers to implement material changes to their compliance regimes. Commenters should consider whether any further changes are necessary to better calibrate these requirements.
- The SEC proposed to require that a fund’s CCO be responsible for oversight of cross trading, including by making certain determinations with respect to valuations. Commenters should consider whether certain oversight obligations would be more effectively managed by other personnel, such as a fund’s valuation designee.
- The SEC’s proposal to permit payment of de minimis fees provides flexibility in light of the Cross-Trading Rule’s prohibition on transaction fees and commissions, but commenters should consider whether the SEC’s description of a de minimis amount adequately captures the types of fees that are commonly charged in cross trades.
- Commissioner Mark Uyeda asked whether the SEC should require transaction-level reporting of cross-trading data. Commenters should consider whether the costs of such a requirement would outweigh the benefits.
- Commenters should consider the appropriateness of the requirement to review the timing and price of subsequent sales of securities purchased in cross trades.
- Commenters should also consider whether the SEC’s statement that any inconsistent prior staff guidance would be superseded by the rule, if adopted, would unnecessarily remove helpful flexibility provided for in existing staff guidance.
Public comments to the proposed rule are due by December 14, 2026. Public comments will be important to encourage the SEC to provide additional flexibility and address operational and other challenges before finalizing the rule changes.
[1] Investment Company Cross Trading, SEC, Investment Company Act Release No. 36358 (October 9, 2026) (Proposing Release).
[2] Id. at 27.
[3] Good Faith Determinations of Fair Value, SEC, Investment Company Act Release No. 34128 (December 3, 2020).
[4] See Proposing Release at 13-14.
[5] Id. at 29.
[6] Id. at 49-50.
[7] Id. at 52.
[8] Id. at 55.
[9] Id. at 56-57.
[10] Id. at 62.
[11] Id. at 63.
[12] Id. at 22.
[13] Id. at 96; see, e.g., Independent Directors Council, SEC Staff No-Action Letter (October 12, 2018) (with respect to Rule 17a-7); Independent Directors Council and Mutual Fund Directors Forum, SEC Staff Letter (November 2, 2010) (with respect to Rule 17a-7).